Inside Chef Rob Gentile’s Buca Yorkville

“The best ingredients” – Chef Rob Gentile uses the phrase repeatedly in our conversation, stressing their importance. The repetition is not redundant, there is no lack of meaning. The ingredients constitute his dharma; they are a representation of his childhood, his family, his education, his mentorship, his pride, his work, his restaurants, and his life.

Like his two previous award-winning restaurants – Buca King Street (described as “Nonna” – the tank, the originator) and Bar Buca (the “spunky nephew”) – Chef Gentile has an ingredient-focused approach to Buca Yorkville (formally titled Buca Osteria & Enoteca), whose maritime twist forms the basis for his somewhat simple — yet sophisticated — new endeavor.

Buca Yorkville

“It’s extremely important to find the best ingredients – that for me, is the most important thing,” he tells me over glasses of sparkling water in the semi-private room at Buca Yorkville. “Everything we do stems from that in the kitchen. The second most important thing is every customer that phones the restaurant and anyone that ever walks in the door. The only reason why they’re the second most important is because I’m the chef, right? In a perfect world, they’re the most important thing — but me being the chef, I’m responsible for the food and I try and make sure that everything is as perfect as possible. The only way I do that is through the ingredients.”

Buca Yorkville

At first glance, the Buca Yorkville menu features structural similarities to the King Street Buca’s offerings. However, the key difference at the uptown outpost is fish and seafood replace many of the original location’s red meat proteins. Bucatini alla carbonara sees toothsome smoked herring bottarga replace the classic guanciale for a remarkably similar taste. Salumi di Buca is substituted for salumi di mare – an exciting range of cured Canadian fish. Crudo of whole branzino is carved tableside. The braised octopus with B.C. clams, bone marrow, black kale, baby artichoke, and fregola sarda is so good, one hopes it never leaves the menu.

Buca Yorkville

“The idea of fish came through our experiences in Italy. The cuisine changed according to the geography of where you were. So if you were close to water, you ate fish. If you were close to land, you ate meat.”

“It just so happens that most of the major cities are inland – the most popular thing happening in Italian food is meat. So when we experienced fish in Italy, it was just like a whole ‘nother level, even for me because we don’t live near an ocean in Toronto, so my family was cooking meat. It was a great feeling. It was super exiting.”

“So it was like, what if we just flipped the concept of King Street? We do the exact same thing, it’s all our food – it’s the same thing in Italy. Here, we use the tuna blood, we’ll cure the heart from the tuna, we’ll do something with the skin from a swordfish, we’ll cook with codfish tongue — and at the same time, we do simple pomodoro dishes; we do simple salads.”

Buca Yorkville

“It’s a mixture of the idea of the ingredients and the idea of, ‘We’ve received the ingredient in its entirety, how do we use all of it?’ Nothing goes to waste ever in Italy… ever! Doesn’t matter what it is.”

There is a strong focus on locality and regionality. The fisheries, waterways, and location of the catch, as well as accompanying ingredients, are given prime real estate on Buca Yorkville’s menu.

“We’re very close with the suppliers that are sending us the fish,” he explains. “I receive photos of the fishermen, I receive photos of the boats. Whether it’s Outlandish Fisherman’s Guild in B.C. or Fisherfolk in Nova Scotia; whether it’s Alex at Société in Quebec, or if it’s Dan at Hooked with his connections; and directly to the people who are either farming or fishing.”

“We get really detailed updates and we translate that all to our employees. We show them pictures, we present them with all the different kinds of fish before service. That’s what keeps us confident in what were doing, because we have good reliable people we’re working with.”

Beyond the education Chef Gentile imparts to his staff, a learning experience is something he strives for with Buca Yorkville’s patrons.

“When I was at Slow Fish in Genoa, the most important message was that, ‘We have the ability to make people listen.'”

“There’s a lot of interesting stuff we’re able to work with that doesn’t come into the Canadian market. It’s available to us because we’re chefs and it’s not to the general public, which is sad.”

“The more that people come into the restaurant and say, ‘I had this arctic char or I had this amazing type of clam,’ or the more that people are aware how much useable product is on a whole tuna or swordfish or even halibut; instead of going for the same salmon that you always see at the grocery store, more people will ask for different species. That’s the only way the market can change.”

Buca Yorkville

As Buca Yorkville ramps up and a fourth project looms – Jamie’s Italian, a collaboration between celebrity chef Jamie Oliver and Gentile’s King Street Food Company, set to drop this spring at Yorkdale – I ask if he fears burning out.

“No. Not a chance. I’ve got a long way to go, man,” he chuckles. “I feel young. I feel young in my heart and I feel young in my accomplishments. I still have a ton of things that I’ve set for myself to get done, so it’s full steam ahead.”

With attitude, ambition, talent and reverence, add Chef Rob Gentile to the list of household names within Canada’s culinary landscape. And if he’s truly made his mark, his appreciation and edification of our local producers and products will transcend the niche and follow in his path.

Are you excited for Buca Yorkville? Let us know in the comments below or tweet us @ViewTheVibe.

Jason Finestone

Jason Finestone

A Toronto based food fiend and travel nut with a lust for all things tasty. If his liver can process it (somewhat) then he’s likely game to give it a go. His wanderlust spirit has taken him all over the globe, living in 6 different countries from Canada to the US, South Korea to Europe. Along the way he’s developed a propensity for irreverent parlance and inhibition-less adventure. “If meat is king then dumplings are queen — I am a prince of noodle soups and a duke of hard drink — street food is life.”
Jason Finestone

Latest posts by Jason Finestone (see all)