Dining at Toronto Island’s Rectory Café One Last Time

rectory cafe

The Rectory Café (Image: Libby Roach)

Centre Island may have been shut down by lack of ferry service, but The Rectory Café lives on. While the media storm has been circling in the usual predatory fashion, painting the recent flooding as the reason for the Rectory’s closing, it’s not. The decision, from owners Ken McAuliffe, Sarah Willinsky & Mark Samuel came back in September when they decided to not renew the lease.

rectory cafe

Owner Ken McAuliffe (Image: Libby Roach)

The business is for sale, and it’s one of the only places on the island to have a liquor license. Indeed, this is a special place. The shady patio is perched perfectly off the wooden plank boardwalk facing Lake Ontario. It’s entirely possible to drift away and feel like you are anywhere else — this isn’t the Toronto most people know. A true hidden gem, The Rectory has one of the best patios in the city, and at the time of visiting, the ferry traffic is almost at a standstill. The island is almost empty, no Centreville-crazed toddlers or sunbathing tourists to disrupt the scene. It’s quite possibly the best time to visit the island.

A glass of rosé (Image: Libby Roach)

Not much pairs better with a pretty sunset than a chilled glass of Hidden Bench Rose ($11 for 5 oz) and a Muskoka chair to sink into. Their wine list boasts many Ontario faves, and some greats from California and Argentina. Cocktails, including sangrias by the pitcher, are worth savouring. The food menu is perfect summer food, too. Yes, burgers and pulled pork sammies but also inspired options like the Labneh ($13), made in-house and partnered with grilled pita, olives and roasted garlic.

rectory cafe

The Labneh (Image: Libby Roach)

While burgers and fries are no stranger to me, the Orange Miso Salmon ($28) is a show stopper — a massive portion of sous vide salmon resting on a bed of crispy bed of quinoa and sautéed bok choy is seasonal and sensational.

rectory cafe

Orange Miso Salmon (Image: Libby Roach)

Desserts are on point too — prepared by in-house Pastry Chef Sergio Crisantes. The Apple Peach Crumb Cake ($10.50) is sublime. Summer, sweet and super moist, it’s a lovely finish to and a way to linger longer and soak up the scenery.

rectory cafe

Apple Peach Crumb Cake (Image: Libby Roach)

The historic building and its long love affair with islanders, tourists and city dwellers such as myself might be coming to a close, but with these amazing bones it’s sure to be snapped by a someone with buckets of money smitten with its significance.

The Rectory isn’t going out quietly though, with loads of events planned through ’til the bittersweet end. They’re currently open from Sunday to Wednesday 11-7pm, Thursday to Saturday from 11-9pm and they accept reservations, too.

RELATED LINK: Toronto Restaurant Openings to Watch out for this August

What’s your favourite memory of The Rectory Café? Share it with us in the comment section or tweet us at @ViewtheVibe

Libby Roach

Libby Roach

Libby Roach is a born and raised Toronto girl and subsequent mortified Leafs fan. When not eating, shooting or writing about food you can find her running around 416-land trying to burn those calories off.
Libby Roach
  • mdewds

    this article is dated August 9 and claims that the Island is closed and ferries are on alimited schedule. In fact, the Island reopened on July 31st and is nearly as busy as any other summer.