‘Tis the season for $15.00 dollar beers, dollar hot dogs, snapback caps, and nosebleed seats at the Rogers Centre (formerly, and preferably known as the SkyDome). Nothing says summertime in Toronto like attending a Blue Jays game with some of your closest friends. No wonder #IloveBJs is taking over our Twitter timelines. You don’t have to like baseball to root for the home team, if you know what we mean. Here are the top twenty (2) hottest Toronto Blue Jays that we’d surely go to home base with, of all time.
When it comes to the Toronto Blue Jays, the love isn’t just about home runs and pennants — it’s about the players who made us swoon, scream, and maybe even daydream a little during those late-inning heroics. From bat-flipping icons to baby-faced rookies with swagger, these Jays didn’t just bring the heat on the field — they brought it in every sense of the word.
So, in honour of Toronto’s ongoing baseball fever (and the World Series buzz that’s taken over the city), here are 20 of the hottest Blue Jays of all time — not ranked, because let’s be honest, beauty and baseball are both subjective.
ADVERTISEMENT |
1. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. – 1B/3B (2019–present)
The face of the modern Blue Jays era. Guerrero Jr. carries the swagger of a superstar with the energy of a fan favourite. His bat speed alone could melt ice on Front Street. From his All-Star appearances to his record-breaking contract extension, he’s the kind of guy who makes fans believe again — and maybe blush a little while he’s at it.
2. Bo Bichette – SS (2019–present)
Bo knows baseball — and how to make a messy bun look red-carpet ready. Between his smooth fielding, effortless power, and smouldering good looks, Bichette has become the Jays’ unofficial heart-throb of the social media era. He’s got the locks, the swing, and the confidence to back it all up.
3. George Springer – OF (2021–present)
When the Jays signed Springer, Toronto collectively swooned. The veteran outfielder brought championship pedigree — and charm — to the roster. His megawatt smile, easy swagger, and clutch performances have cemented him as one of the most loveable and good-looking players in recent Jays history.
4. Addison Barger – OF/INF (2023–present)
The new kid on the block with instant star appeal. After his pinch-hit grand slam in the World Series, Addison Barger became Toronto’s newest obsession. Rugged, humble, and oozing “next-big-thing” energy, he’s already proving that confidence and charisma are the new uniforms in town.
ADVERTISEMENT |
5. José Bautista – RF/3B (2008–2017)
The bat-flip heard around the world wasn’t just iconic — it was sexy. Bautista embodied Blue Jays swagger in its purest form: beard, biceps, and boldness. He turned Toronto into a baseball town again and made attitude fashionable long before TikTok discovered thirst traps.
6. Edwin Encarnación – DH/1B (2011–2016)
The man with the “Parrot Walk.” Edwin brought joy to every home run and fire to every at-bat. Beyond his powerful swing, his charm and quiet confidence made him a fan favourite both on and off the field. A Blue Jays heart-throb with an unforgettable smile — and one seriously smooth home-run trot.
7. Josh Donaldson – 3B (2015–2018)
The “Bringer of Rain” brought more than thunder. With his golden hair, piercing eyes, and MVP swagger, Donaldson was every bit the rock-star athlete. He played hard, looked good doing it, and knew it. The perfect mix of grit and glam from Toronto’s mid-2010s glory run.
8. Marcus Stroman – SP (2014–2019)
Stroman’s confidence was his superpower. Tattooed, fiery, and unapologetically himself, he was one of the most charismatic pitchers to ever wear the Jays’ blue. Fans loved his intensity — and, let’s be real, his drip. Off the field, his fits were as sharp as his slider.
9. Aaron Sanchez – SP (2014–2018)
Before injuries slowed him down, Aaron Sanchez was the definition of a young phenom. That hair, that smile, that curveball — Toronto fell hard. He dominated on the mound and looked like a Hollywood casting call for “heart-throb pitcher.”
ADVERTISEMENT |
10. Carlos Delgado – 1B (1993–2004)
Delgado was power personified. Calm, consistent, and quietly magnetic, he became one of the Jays’ all-time greats. Off the field, he had an easy confidence and warmth that made him as endearing as he was dominant. Think gentle giant energy with 40-home-run power.
11. Shawn Green – OF (1995–2001)
Shawn Green was the clean-cut heart-throb every mom loved. Tall, blue-eyed, and consistently clutch, he combined California cool with Canadian charm. A fan favourite from day one, he made hitting home runs look like an art form — and somehow never broke a sweat doing it.
12. Joe Carter – OF/1B (1991–1997)
The man who gave Toronto its most unforgettable baseball moment. Carter’s walk-off homer in the 1993 World Series wasn’t just history — it was pure cinematic magic. He had the smile, the charisma, and the kind of confidence that made everyone root for him.
ADVERTISEMENT |
13. Devon White – CF (1991–1995)
Smooth, sleek, and always composed. Devon White patrolled centre field like a catwalk — graceful, poised, and impossible to look away from. His defense was art, his demeanor was pure class, and his presence made every play feel effortless.
14. Tony Fernández – SS (1983–1990, 1993, 1998–1999, 2001)
Elegance defined Tony Fernández. The late shortstop was a magician with the glove and a gentleman off the field. His quiet grace and easy smile made him one of the most beloved players in franchise history — and a true icon of 1980s Toronto baseball.
15. Fred McGriff – 1B (1986–1990)
Before he was “The Crime Dog,” Fred McGriff was one of the Jays’ most handsome sluggers. Strong, stoic, and serious about his game, he had that timeless ‘80s athlete look — the kind you’d expect to see in a baseball card and on a GQ cover.
ADVERTISEMENT |
16. Roy Halladay – SP (1998–2009)
“Doc” wasn’t flashy — he didn’t need to be. His precision, focus, and quiet intensity made him irresistible to fans who appreciated substance over style. Halladay was stoic, commanding, and the ultimate “strong, silent type.” Pure class through and through.
17. Kevin Pillar – OF (2013–2019)
Superman dives, piercing eyes, and rugged charm — Kevin Pillar had it all. Known for sacrificing his body for jaw-dropping catches, he brought grit and good looks in equal measure. Fans adored his hustle, but let’s be honest, the jawline didn’t hurt either.
18. Troy Tulowitzki – SS (2015–2017)
Tulowitzki’s Jays tenure may have been short, but it was impactful. The former All-Star shortstop turned heads from the moment he arrived — both for his slick fielding and his movie-star good looks. He had that “strong and silent” vibe that could light up the Rogers Centre.
ADVERTISEMENT |
19. Roberto Alomar – 2B (1991–1995)
Before the controversies, there was the legend. Alomar was the definition of baseball elegance — the switch-hitting, Gold Glove-winning infielder who helped deliver Toronto’s back-to-back World Series titles. Smooth, stylish, and electric on the field, he was once the city’s golden boy.
20. Alek Manoah – SP (2021–present)
When he’s on, Manoah is electric — and his confidence is magnetic. Big personality, big frame, big energy. From his trash-talk moments to his bulldog mentality, he’s become one of Toronto’s most recognizable modern players. He’s got that “don’t mess with me” charm fans love.
Who do you think is the hottest Toronto Blue Jays player? Let us know by slipping into our DMs over at @ViewTheVibe.
ADVERTISEMENT |
Originally written in June 2015, further updated June 2025 and most recently updated during the World Series games in October 2025.
